The Follow-Up That Saved the Deal
Rachel sent what she thought was a perfect first DM. The prospect opened it. Read it. And... nothing. Silence. After three days, Rachel panicked. Should she follow up? Would she seem desperate? Would he think she was spamming him?
She waited a week. Then sent a single-line nudge: "Hey Tom, following up on my message from last week. Any thoughts?"
Still nothing.
Meanwhile, her colleague Jason had the same thing happen. First DM, no reply. But Jason didn't send a generic bump. Five days later, he sent this: "Tom—saw your team just shipped the new dashboard feature. Congrats! That reminded me of the question I asked last week about onboarding flows. Still curious to hear how you think about progressive disclosure vs. showing everything upfront."
Tom replied in 20 minutes: "Sorry I missed this! Progressive disclosure 100%. Want to jump on a quick call?"
Same situation. Completely different outcome. The difference? Rachel nudged. Jason added value. And that's the secret to LinkedIn follow up messages that actually work: every touch should give the recipient a reason to engage, not just a reminder that you exist.
Why Most LinkedIn Follow-Ups Fail (And Feel Pushy)
Let's be honest: most follow-ups fail because they're about you, not them. "Just checking in." "Bumping this up in your inbox." "Wanted to make sure you saw this." These phrases all translate to the same thing: "I want something from you and you're ignoring me."
The problem isn't that you followed up. It's that you didn't give the recipient a reason to reply. You just reminded them they didn't reply the first time—which makes them feel guilty or annoyed, neither of which leads to a conversation.
Pushy vs. Helpful Follow-Ups
Here's the shift you need to make:
- Pushy follow-up: "Did you see my last message?"
- Helpful follow-up: "Saw [new context]. Made me think of [topic we discussed]. Quick question: [something specific]."
Helpful follow-ups don't feel like follow-ups at all. They feel like new messages that happen to reference the first one. They add fresh context, ask better questions, or offer something useful. And because they're recipient-focused, they don't trigger the "ugh, this person again" reaction that kills conversations.
This is the same relational mindset that powers all authentic LinkedIn networking: you're not chasing—you're cultivating.
The 3-Touch Follow-Up Cadence That Works
Here's the proven cadence for LinkedIn follow up messages: three touches over 14 days, each one adding value, not pressure.
Touch 1: Day 0 (The First DM)
Your first message sets the tone. It should follow the Context → Relevance → Light Ask framework from our first DM guide. Keep it short, specific, and easy to reply to.
Example:
"Sarah—loved your take on pricing psychology in yesterday's post. Quick question: have you seen freemium models work for B2B SaaS, or do they mostly just attract tire-kickers?"
Touch 2: Day 5-7 (The Value-Add Follow-Up)
If they haven't replied after 5-7 days, send a follow-up that introduces new context or value. Don't just bump the original message—expand on it.
Example:
"Sarah—circling back on the freemium question. I just came across a case study from [Company] that addressed this exact thing. They pivoted from freemium to a free trial + paid onboarding model and saw conversions jump 40%. Thought you might find it interesting. (Link in comments if useful.)"
Notice what this does: it doesn't say "Did you see my message?" It builds on the original message by adding something new. You're not nagging—you're continuing a conversation.
Touch 3: Day 12-14 (The Soft Close)
If still no reply, send a final message that gracefully closes the loop while leaving the door open. This is your "permission to move on" moment.
Example:
"Sarah—totally understand if this isn't the right time. I'll stop cluttering your inbox! But if pricing strategy ever becomes a priority, feel free to reach out. Happy to share what's worked (and what's flopped) for us."
This accomplishes two things: it shows you respect their time, and it gives them an easy way to re-engage later without feeling awkward. Sometimes people come back weeks later with "Hey, sorry I missed this—let's chat."
6 Follow-Up Scripts That Add Value, Not Pressure
Here are six proven follow-up templates for different scenarios. Each one introduces new context, value, or relevance—never just "bumping."
Script 1: New Insight or Resource
"Hey Alex—I know you're busy, but I just read [article/study] that ties directly into the question I asked last week about [topic]. Key takeaway: [one sentence]. Thought you'd appreciate it given your work on [their project]."
Script 2: Trigger Event
"Congrats on [new hire, product launch, funding news], Lisa! That must be keeping you swamped. When things settle, I'd still love your take on [original question]. No rush—just wanted to acknowledge the big news."
Script 3: Social Proof
"Jordan—since I messaged you last week, I've had three other [role] tell me the same thing about [topic]. Seems like this is a widespread challenge. Still curious how you're thinking about it on your end."
Script 4: Mutual Connection Mention
"Tom—I was chatting with [Mutual connection] yesterday and your name came up. They said you're the person to ask about [topic]. Circling back on my question from last week—still curious to hear your thoughts if you have a minute."
Script 5: Content Callback
"Priya—just saw your latest post on [topic]. That line about [specific point] was gold. Made me think of the question I asked last week about [related topic]. Any chance you've got a quick take on that too?"
Script 6: The Honest Closer
"Hey Rachel—I realize I might have caught you at a busy time. No worries if this isn't a priority right now. If it ever becomes relevant, feel free to ping me. Otherwise, I'll stop filling up your inbox!"
Each of these scripts respects the recipient's attention while giving them a clear, low-pressure reason to reply. And when follow-ups feel helpful instead of demanding, response rates go up dramatically.
Timing Cues: When to Follow Up (And When to Move On)
Timing matters as much as what you say. Here's how to read the signals:
- If they opened but didn't reply within 48 hours: They're either too busy, not interested, or waiting to see if you're persistent. Wait 5-7 days, then follow up with new value.
- If they didn't open at all: Your message might be buried. Wait 5-7 days and try again. If still no open after touch 2, they're probably not active on LinkedIn—move on.
- If they viewed your profile but didn't reply: Good sign—they're interested but not ready to engage. Follow up with a softer, relationship-building message (not a hard ask).
- If they replied but didn't answer your question: They're engaging, just busy. Keep the conversation going with a new question or insight. Don't repeat yourself.
And remember: following up is a skill that works hand-in-hand with staying organized. If you're managing dozens of conversations, you need a system. Learn how to organize LinkedIn relationships so you never lose track of who you've messaged and when.
Case Study: The Follow-Up That Turned a No-Reply Into a Meeting
Let's break down a real example (names changed) of a follow-up sequence that worked.
First message (Day 0):
"Mark—saw you just joined [Company] as VP of Sales. Congrats! Quick question: when you're rebuilding a sales org from scratch, do you hire generalists first or specialists?"
No reply.
Follow-up 1 (Day 6):
"Mark—circling back. I just interviewed three sales leaders who all said 'hire athletes, teach the playbook.' But I'm skeptical. Curious if you've seen that work, or if domain expertise still matters more than people think."
Still no reply. But Mark viewed the sender's profile.
Follow-up 2 (Day 13):
"Mark—totally understand if you're heads-down with the new role. Last thing before I stop bothering you: I'm compiling a resource on sales hiring best practices and your perspective would be incredibly valuable. If you've got 15 minutes in the next two weeks, I'd love to chat. If not, no worries—and good luck with the build!"
Mark replied: "Sorry for the delay—it's been chaos. Would love to chat. Here's my Calendly."
The meeting happened. The follow-ups worked because they were patient, value-focused, and gave Mark multiple reasons to engage without making him feel pressured. That's the playbook.
Common Follow-Up Mistakes to Avoid
- Following up too soon: Waiting only 24-48 hours makes you look desperate. Give it 5-7 days minimum.
- Repeating yourself: Don't resend the same message. Add new context, value, or relevance every time.
- Being vague: "Just checking in" is code for "I have nothing new to say." Be specific.
- Apologizing excessively: One "sorry to bother you" is fine. Multiple apologies make you sound insecure.
- Ignoring signals: If they're not opening or engaging after 2-3 touches, move on. Don't be the person who sends 10 follow-ups.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many follow-ups is too many?
Three is the sweet spot. First message + two follow-ups over 14 days. If there's still no reply, move on. Anything beyond that crosses into spam territory and damages your reputation.
Should I apologize for following up?
A brief acknowledgment ("I know you're busy") is fine, but don't over-apologize. It makes you sound like you're bothering them—which kills your credibility. Stay confident and value-focused.
What if they reply but the conversation stalls again?
Treat it like a new sequence. Wait a few days, then follow up with fresh context or value. As long as they've shown interest once, they're worth re-engaging—just don't force it.
Next step: Take control of your LinkedIn relationships — Try ANDI Free.
