The Reciprocity Playbook: How to Get LinkedIn Recommendations by Giving First

The Recommendation Drought

Marcus had been on LinkedIn for five years. He'd worked with dozens of talented colleagues, delivered strong results for multiple clients, and built solid relationships along the way. But his LinkedIn profile had zero recommendations. Not because people didn't value his work—but because he'd never asked. And honestly, asking felt awkward.

Then a recruiter reached out about a dream role. The first thing they did? Check his LinkedIn profile. No recommendations. No social proof. Just his own words about his skills and accomplishments. The recruiter hesitated. "Is this person as good as they say? Has anyone else vouched for them?" Marcus didn't make it past the first round.

That's when he discovered the LinkedIn recommendation reciprocity strategy. Instead of asking for recommendations, he started giving them. He wrote thoughtful, specific recommendations for three former colleagues. Within a week, two of them reciprocated without being asked. Within a month, he had six recommendations on his profile. The next time a recruiter landed on his page, his credibility was undeniable.

In this playbook, you'll learn how to use reciprocity—the psychological principle that people feel compelled to return favors—to earn authentic LinkedIn recommendations that strengthen your profile and build trust.

Why Reciprocity Works (And Why Asking Directly Often Doesn't)

Reciprocity is one of the most powerful principles in human psychology. When someone does something for you, you naturally feel a pull to do something for them in return. This isn't manipulation—it's how relationships work.

On LinkedIn, reciprocity plays out like this:

• When you write someone a recommendation, they're reminded of your working relationship — It brings positive memories to the surface and primes them to think about your contributions
• They feel a natural obligation to reciprocate — Not in a guilty way, but in a "I should return the favor" way
• It's easier to say yes to a recommendation you've already received — The effort has already been made for them; reciprocating feels fair

Contrast this with directly asking for a recommendation: "Hey, could you write me a LinkedIn recommendation?" It puts the burden on them. They have to think about what to say, find the time, and do the work—all with nothing in return. Reciprocity flips the dynamic. You give first, and they naturally feel motivated to give back.

The Reciprocity Playbook: Step-by-Step

Here's how to systematically use reciprocity to fill your LinkedIn profile with strong, authentic recommendations.

💡 Step 1: Identify 5-10 People to Recommend

Who to choose: Focus on people you've worked closely with in the past 5 years. Prioritize:

• Former managers or team leads (their recommendations carry extra weight)
• Colleagues who directly saw your work and results
• Clients or customers you delivered value for
• People who are active on LinkedIn (they're more likely to see and reciprocate)

Pro tip: Choose people you genuinely respect and can write a thoughtful recommendation for. Authenticity matters. If your recommendation feels generic or forced, reciprocation is less likely.

✔️ Step 2: Write Strong, Specific Recommendations

Your recommendation should be thoughtful and specific—not a vague endorsement. Here's a simple 3-part structure:

1. Context: How you worked together and in what capacity. Example: "I worked with Sarah for two years at XYZ Company, where she led our product design team."
2. Strengths: 2-3 specific skills or qualities they demonstrated, with concrete examples. Example: "She has an incredible ability to balance user needs with business goals. Her redesign of our onboarding flow increased activation rates by 35%."
3. Endorsement: A clear statement that you'd work with them again or recommend them to others. Example: "I'd jump at the chance to work with Sarah again, and I recommend her without hesitation to any team looking for a sharp, strategic product designer."

Length: Aim for 3-5 sentences (100-150 words). Long enough to be meaningful, short enough to be readable.

"A great recommendation doesn't just say someone is skilled—it shows why. Specific examples and context make the difference between a forgettable endorsement and one that builds real credibility."

🔁 Step 3: Send the Recommendation (Without Asking for One Back)

What to do:

1. Go to the person's LinkedIn profile
2. Scroll to the "Recommendations" section and click "Recommend [Name]"
3. Fill out the form: your working relationship, the position they held, and your recommendation text
4. Hit "Send"

Critical rule: Do NOT mention reciprocity in your message. Don't say "I'd love one in return" or "Hope you can write one for me too." Let the psychology do the work. The recommendation itself is the trigger.

Optional: After sending, you can message them separately with something like: "Hey [Name], I just wrote you a LinkedIn recommendation—wanted to highlight the great work we did together at [Company]. Hope you're doing well!" This is friendly and doesn't ask for anything. It just ensures they see it.

🧠 Step 4: Wait for Reciprocation (It Happens Naturally 60-70% of the Time)

What to expect: Within 1-2 weeks, 60-70% of people you recommend will reciprocate without being asked. LinkedIn notifies them when you write a recommendation, and the platform makes it easy to write one back (they'll see a prompt saying "Return the favor").

If they don't reciprocate immediately: Don't worry. Some people take longer. Others might not be active on LinkedIn. If 2-3 weeks pass and you haven't heard back, you can follow up (Step 5).

✔️ Step 5: If Needed, Follow Up Gently After 2-3 Weeks

What to say: If reciprocation hasn't happened naturally, send a light, friendly message:

"Hey [Name], I hope you're doing well! I wrote you a LinkedIn recommendation a few weeks ago and wanted to check if you'd be open to writing one for me as well. I'd really appreciate it—no pressure if you're swamped!"

This is polite, low-pressure, and acknowledges their time. Most people will say yes at this point because you've already given first.

What Makes Reciprocity Work (And When It Doesn't)

Reciprocity is powerful, but it's not magic. Here's what increases the likelihood of getting recommendations back:

✔️ Factors That Increase Reciprocity

• You write a thoughtful, specific recommendation — Generic praise doesn't inspire reciprocation. Specificity does.
• You had a positive working relationship — People reciprocate more when they genuinely enjoyed working with you.
• The person is active on LinkedIn — If they haven't logged in for months, they might not see your recommendation.
• You recommend multiple people over time — Consistent generosity builds a reputation that encourages reciprocity.

❌ Factors That Reduce Reciprocity

• Your recommendation is vague or templated — "Great to work with!" doesn't inspire much response.
• You immediately ask for one back — This kills the psychology of reciprocity and feels transactional.
• You didn't work closely with the person — Recommending someone you barely know feels inauthentic and won't trigger reciprocity.

Frequently Asked Questions

How many people should I recommend at once?

Start with 3-5 people in the first week, then add 1-2 more each week over the following month. This feels natural and gives you time to write thoughtful recommendations. Recommending 20 people in one day looks spammy and dilutes the personal touch.

Should I only recommend people if I expect reciprocity?

No. Recommend people because you genuinely want to support them. Reciprocity is a bonus, not the sole goal. If you're only recommending people transactionally, it shows—and it hurts authenticity. That said, prioritizing people you've worked closely with increases the likelihood of reciprocation.

What if someone writes me a recommendation first—should I reciprocate?

Absolutely. If someone recommends you first, reciprocating is not only polite—it's expected. Write them a thoughtful recommendation within a week or two. This reinforces the relationship and signals you value their endorsement.

Can I use recommendation templates for faster writing?

Templates can help you get started, but always customize them. Generic recommendations don't inspire reciprocity. Use a template as scaffolding, then add specific examples, results, and personal touches. For pre-built frameworks, check our guide on LinkedIn recommendation request templates.

Reciprocity isn't a shortcut—it's a relationship-building strategy. When you give thoughtful recommendations first, you trigger a natural cycle of generosity and credibility. Your profile fills up with authentic endorsements, and your professional network strengthens. Give first, and watch what comes back.

Next step: Take control of your LinkedIn relationships — Try ANDI Free.